Rating : 7.5/10
First review on the blog with one of my most anticipated reads of 2017 ! 🙂
And I should have learned by now to keep my expectations reasonable ! Don’t get me wrong ! This was a pretty good book and a debut, at that !! But despite bringing together amazing Fantasy elements and magic systems, Promise of Blood didn’t blow my mind and there were some details that bothered me a bit (and that I will list below).
The age of kings is dead, […] and I have killed it.”
So this is my second attempt to read Flintlock Fantasy and I must say, this is a genre I will gladly try again ! In Promise of Blood, the equilibrium between magic and technology was totally enthralling !
People do not exist to serve their governments or their kings. Governments exist to serve the people, so the people should have a say in those governments.
Against a backdrop of French revolution, a complex story of revenge, deception, betrayal, emancipation, survival and justice is told from 3 main POVs : a Field Marshal, a detective and a particularly skilled soldier. Numerous tropes and genres intertwined in the book in perfect harmony : fantasy, military tactics, investigation, religions, politics… You name it ! Honestly, the way Brian McClellan juggled all these elements was fascinating !
“It’s a poor commander who gives in to the whims of his troops,” (he) said. “And an even worse one who ignores their wants and needs.”
Promise of Blood had a LOT of great historical and fictional influences imo. The magic systems were pretty intricate but one of the magics, in its principle, was in a way reminiscent of Allomancy (Mistborn) so I wasn’t very surprised to learn that Brian McClellan has attended Sanderson’s writing classes ! 😀 But be assured, despite the slight similarity, the magic systems in Powder Mage are totally creative! I also got my fair share of Fullmetal Alchemist vibes and it made me sooo happy because I’m an absolute fan of FMA and it brought me both a nostalgic touch and a closeness to McClellan’s world !
McClellan’s writing was pretty sober and not very sophisticated. The worldbuilding was cleverly done and the historical/mythological/magical explanations were progressively introduced. As the story unfolded, the plot thickened as more protagonists entered the game, some in plain sight others placing their pawns and tugging at the strings in the shadows. Political intrigues, subterfuges and mysteries within mysteries are enough to keep you intrigued until the final climax !
Then what went wrong ?
Despite all the great vibes and a cast of rather compelling characters, the story didn’t totally grip me. I enjoyed it but I didn’t love it. I was mesmerized when I was reading but when I had free time, I didn’t die to pick up the book again. And it made me terribly sad ! Because I wanted to love this book so badly ! But :
☹ Some chapters lacked introspection. There were times where I felt very indifferent to what happened to some protagonists: One major character found himself in a dire and kinda tragic situation and he just accepted it !! No denial, no despair, no rage. So I felt very detached at times and I couldn’t bring myself to fully love or care about the characters (except two of them).
☹ The book seemed like a succession of stories, each one having its closure before moving to the next with usually a 5 (or more) days leap. Which made the whole story a bit disjointed at times. And more importantly, some closures happened so fast, the tension didn’t have enough time to build up fully before it was already over.
☹ The lack of female lead characters ! 3 main male POVs and a tiny female POV! Some people may argue that considering the time setting (18 to 19th century), women didn’t get access to high governmental or military functions. Well that’s precisely my problem: women did get access to important positions in the book. Councils, workers unions, army, powerful sorcery cabals… and yet women were mainly relegated to roles of secondary importance, roles of villains or roles of sexual objects (Harems were as natural and common in this relatively modern society as female soldiers. And those were pretty common) ! Why didn’t Ka-Poel get a POV ? Why didn’t Vlora or Julene or Rozalia get one ?? A close friend of mine asked me if women were poorly handled in this book and honestly I don’t really think so because some of the female characters showed interesting and promising development and amazing skills so I still have hope for the next books ! I just regret that they don’t get as much importance and space than their male counterparts.
Despite these points, this was a very good and enjoyable debut. I loved how some of the main characters weren’t completely good or bad but more like real persons with struggles and doubts and tough choices and with equal potential to cruelty and to honor and kindness and justice. I loved the lore and myths and how religion was handled in this book. I also loved the comical situations and the sassy retorts the author included in his rather brutal setting.
If you’re fan of Flintlock Fantasy (or just Fantasy, really), you will probably love this book ! And though it’s only the first book of the trilogy and despite my complaints, I truly recommend Promise of Blood because it has a lot of compelling elements and influences to satisfy a wide range of readers ! I just regret I didn’t love it more.
Review by Haïfa
Read in April, 2017.